carp pic

[Jigman13]

Originally Posted by MudCat08

Those carp are huge, well done!

In my opinion they taste good when fried, but only if they are young carp around 1lb in size (usually 16" or so.) Then they have a decent sweet white meat flavor. When they get old like that, they taste horrible haha.

Too bad most of NJ carp habitats are heavily polluted rivers anyway.

I'd love to find a spot to catch young carp like that.

[Super]

Originally Posted by MudCat08

Too bad most of NJ carp habitats are heavily polluted rivers anyway.

Round Valley, Spruce Run and especially the Delaware River have carp. I wouldn't worry about eating those fish. But carp tolerate pollution really well and there are so many places where I wouldn't even think about eating one.

[Mark B.]

Statewide Freshwater Advisories: Common Carp – General Population: Eat no more than one meal / month. High Risk Population: Do Not Eat.

Carnegie Lake: Common Carp - General Population: Eat no more than one meal / month. High Risk Population: Eat no more than one meal / month.

The above from pages 11 & 16 of: http://www.nj.gov/dep/dsr/fishadviso...advisories.pdf

[Heronimo42]

The amount of pollution, heavy metals and who knows what else is sitting on the bottom of Carnegie...not sure you're doing anyone a favor by giving them carp to eat.

[MudCat08]

Spruce run is probably one of the cleaner areas to get carp from. Monksville and surrounding lakes/reservoirs shouldn't be too bad either. Most will be larger older fish though.

Round valley is clean too but I wasn't aware of carp in there? Usually carp waters are muddier as they love to dig..

[JimmyL]

one heavy weekend for sure...how's your arms?

[Jigman13]

Originally Posted by MudCat08

Spruce run is probably one of the cleaner areas to get carp from. Monksville and surrounding lakes/reservoirs shouldn't be too bad either. Most will be larger older fish though.

Round valley is clean too but I wasn't aware of carp in there? Usually carp waters are muddier as they love to dig..

There are beer keg sized carp in rvr.