bait runner reel

[bbills4x]

Trying to decide between a penn spin fisher 4500 live liner or a shimano bait runner 4000d for use on a 8ft rod from a pier and on a party boat for stripers, which is the better choice from experience, thanks

[SplitShot]

MY Vote: Shimano

[swcody13]

The spinfisher ratio is over 6 which in my opinion is too high for the application. Shimano's Baitrunner is Definitely under 5, I believe 4.8:1 which is a "just-right" feel for the kind of fishing a Baitrunner would be used for. I'd go with shimano also

[MrAC1980]

Like others have said, go with the Shimano and dont look back.

[june181901]

I use a Shimano and have no complaints. Not used a Penn bait runner.

[catfishonthelake]

You definitely won't be disappointed with the Shimano. Just a word to the wise...I have a couple of those 4000's that I use for carp fishing. They're smaller than you'd think. Just make sure you hold one in your hand if you're gonna order online or you might be disappointed.

[rubberheels]

Shimano ALLWAYS!

[bbills4x]

Ended up purchasing the Shimano bait runner 6000d, thanks for the input

[jlrotary]

FWIW I purchased a Shimano bait runner and had issues after 3 trips. Shimano didn't repair it, but replaced it. A week later a package came from them and in it was the spool with braid from the damaged reel. So I ended up with a free spare. Good customer service.

[Gerry Zagorski]

I have the 8000d Shimano and it's been good. Don't use it all that much since I mostly fish conventionals. Had it for 4 seasons and the handle got tight, one of the bearings started to grind and the bail springs were sticking. Sent it back to Shimano and for $30 they fixed everything and its working like new.

The 8000 might be a little big for your needs and the 4000 too small. I think the 6000 might be a good choice.