NJ Fishing Advertise Here at New Jersey's Number 1 Fishing Website!

Message Board

RFA Pushes For Flexibility Bill - NJFishing.com Your Best Online Source for Fishing Information in New Jersey

Message Board Registration       FAQ

Go Back   NJFishing.com Your Best Online Source for Fishing Information in New Jersey > NJFishing.com Fisheries Management/Regulations
FAQ Members List Calendar Mark Forums Read

NJFishing.com Fisheries Management/Regulations This board is closed for posting but will serve as an archieve for all Fisheries Management and Regulations posts from other boards.

Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-27-2010, 10:33 AM
dales529 dales529 is offline
NJFishing.com Old Salt
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 2,644
Default RFA Pushes For Flexibility Bill

"Unless We Unite...Sportfishing Is In Big Trouble"

When the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) closed the recreational amberjack
fishery on October 24, it was essentially the shot heard round the American docks.
NMFS had made a similar emergency closure on the black sea bass fishery in federal
waters north of Cape Hatteras, NC just three weeks prior - a fishery which remains
closed to recreational fishermen to this day - while the decision had already been
made through NMFS and the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council to close all
bottom fishing in over 1000 square miles of coastal waters from North Carolina
to Florida to protect and rebuild the red snapper populations.

In 2006, the Magnuson Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Reauthorization
Act (MSA) was passed in the Senate by "unanimous consent" - and signed into law
by then President G.W. Bush soon after. The act of unanimous consent on the floor
of the Senate officially sets aside rules of procedure so as to expedite proceedings.
The quick passage of MSA in the Senate helped to memorialize Sen. Ted Stevens in
the naming of our federal fisheries law before his departure from office, and it
also facilitated the rapid progression of this broken federal fisheries law without
any debate on the floor.

For the past five years, the Recreational Fishing Alliance (RFA) has been quite
vocal in its opposition to "time-specific" deadlines and the arbitrary, non-scientific
provisions contained within MSA. The inflexibility of the fisheries law to respond
to an ever-changing marine ecosystem coupled with grossly inadequate management
information systems within our federal fisheries service is contributing to a major
industry collapse which has been felt throughout our coastal communities. Through
strict enforcement of the provisions of MSA, and the rapidly expanding denial of
public access to rebuilt and rebuilding fisheries, it has become extremely clear
to the majority of anglers and fishing organizations that the federal fisheries
law must be fixed.

After spending nearly 10 years in the tackle industry as editor of one of America's
leading recreational fishing publications, and now as managing director of the RFA,
I'm often asked by friends and associates as to where the "industry" stands on the
continued closures, overly restrictive regulations, and the ideological warfare
brought upon our coastal communities by well-funded preservationists. The radical
environmental movement funded by Pew Charitable Trusts has helped alter fisheries
rebuilding parameters and they've effectively redefined the term "overfishing" to
allow for economically and socially destructive measures to be enacted upon rebuilding
fish stocks. The bad news for anglers is that many of our national fishing organizations
have aligned themselves with the ultra-conservation front in believing that MSA
is working just fine, and that once fish stocks are rebuilt to "optimum yield" then
everything will be alright.

In arecent article at ESPN Outdoors
the Center for Coastal Conservation (CCC) said "we do not believe a legislative
'fix' that permits continued overfishing indefinitely is the way to go," while adding
that instead of fixing Magnuson, RFA's efforts "would be better focused on creating
free markets for catch shares, leveraged buyouts to right-size overcapitalized fleets,
and implementing economic and science-supported fisheries management decisions that
put the resource first."

The RFA's message back to CCC, and its "institutional sustainers" and partners at
the American Sportfishing Association, the Billfish Foundation, the Coastal Conservation
Association, the International Game Fish Association and the National Marine Manufacturers
Association is this: our recreational fishing community remainssteadfastly and vehemently
opposed to catch shares and
any other privatization schemes which attempt to eliminate open access fishing to
the exclusion of the American fishing public. Furthermore, to "put the resource
first" is a tired cliche; recreational fishermen, like all sportsman, have always
"put the resource first." The fact is that a fishery resource can only be defined
as a resource if you have both the fish and the fishermen - simply put, a resource
can never be first when you're a non-user!

The good news is that the majority of fishing organizations and industry leaders
in America today feel as strongly as we do about fixing Magnuson. On February 24,
2010, be sure to join us on the steps of the U.S. Capitol in a rally to protect
our coastal communities. As Bob Flocken of the Southern Kingfish Association (SKA)
said recently in a newsletter blast to his industry partners, "The situation is
much more severe than you may realize and unless we unite and put our money where
our mouth is, sport fishing is in big trouble."
Jim Hutchinson, Jr.
RFA Managing Director
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
RFA-NJ Member
Old 01-27-2010, 10:37 AM
dales529 dales529 is offline
NJFishing.com Old Salt
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 2,644
Default Re: RFA Pushes For Flexibility Bill

Balance of article:

Dear Industry Partner,
Today, your company has the opportunity to unite with other industry members to
help stop the insane and unnecessary regulations that the federal government is
trying to force down our throats. Anglers across the country are losing their right
to fish because of actions that the National Marine Fisheries Service (NFMS) is
taking. The situation is much more severe than you may realize and unless we unite
and put our money where our mouth is, sport fishing is in big trouble. If we fail
to act quickly, we very well might be witnessing the last nail in our industry's
Wording included during the last reauthorization of the Magnuson-Stevens Act (MSA)
in 2007 mandated that all fish stocks must be rebuilt to "maximum sustainable" levels
within arbitrarily determined time frames that have no basis in science. In addition,
the law gives fishery management councils only one year to implement regulatory
action for any fishery that may be deemed "overfished," and environmentalists are
using that term as a scare tactic.
Recently the NMFS and the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council told fishermen
that they were "required by law" to close all bottom fishing in over 1000 square
miles of coastal waters from North Carolina to Florida to protect and rebuild the
red snapper populations, even though they readily admit to having insufficient scientific
data to make a accurate determination of the health of the stock. They also blame
Congress for not allocating sufficient funds to do the necessary research to provide
the data needed, yet the MSA forces them to close the fishery, regardless of the
socioeconomic consequences.
The NMFS Regional Administrator, Roy Crabtree, told me that the law leaves them
no choice, but to close the fishery for seventeen to thirty-five years to achieve
the desired stock level required by Magnuson-Stevens. Because red snapper is one
of the most popular recreational fish in some of the most populous fishing states
in the country, such a closure will destroy a viable fishery and seriously affect
the many small businesses that are already struggling under the current economic
These long term closures fall nicely into the well laid plans of Jane Lubchenco,
President Obama's appointment as director of NOAA, the ultimate power overseeing
NMFS and the fishery councils. Where do her loyalties really lie? From her past
history, it is quite obvious that she is speaking out of both sides of her mouth.
She has told everyone that she is looking out for the "interests of recreational
fishermen," but since the early 1970's, Ms. Lubchenco, her husband, friends and
colleagues have received millions of dollars in funding from the Pew Charitable
Trust, an organization that has literally hijacked the fishery management system
in our country.
Such closures are only the first of many species that PEW has targeted. This group
of environmental zealots has a multi-billion dollar war chest courtesy of oil industry
profits and they are spending millions to influence government policy that will
lead to the end of all fishing along the entire U.S. coastline.
President Obama has expressed his desires to turn over control of the oceans to
a "World Organization". In addition, members of our federal government already have
legislation in both the House and Senate proposing that the federal government take
control of all natural watersheds away from the states. If this comes to pass, freshwater
fishermen will soon be facing these same problems saltwater anglers are already
facing. Because of the MSA and concessions made by states along the West Coast,
the government has already instituted plans to permanently close an additional
30% of California's coastal waters to all fishing. They are also looking at more
closures on the East and West Coasts, in the Gulf of Mexico and Florida Keys as
well as a large part of Miami's Biscayne Bay. Jane Lubchenco is a strong proponent
of marine reserves that ban all fishing and authored several of her earliest papers
promoting their widespread use.
Congress currently allows for flexibility when dealing with clean water and clean
air efforts, so as not to completely shut down related industries and eliminate
jobs on a wholesale basis, while continuing to make progress with these two very
important issues. Why then, when Congress deals with fisheries and fishermen, is
it okay to shut down fisheries using inflexible, arbitrary deadlines based on insufficient,
unsubstantiated science, with no regard to the socioeconomic impact. In order to
stop this insanity the MSA must be amended immediately.
The "Flexibility in Rebuilding American Fisheries Act", has been a priority of the
Recreational Fishing Alliance since 2007. It was submitted by Rep. Frank Pallone
(D-NJ) and Rep. John Mica (R-FL) in the House as H.R. 1584 and the long awaited
Senate companion bill, S. 1225, was recently introduced by Senator Charles Schumer
(D-NY). This legislation addresses the inflexibility of the current language and
brings it into line with the Clean Water and Clean Air Bills that have been so
successful. The legislation is not only good for America's recreational and commercial
fishermen, but will help all the small businesses that are being destroyed by unwarranted
and unnecessary regulatory actions. It does not weaken conservation efforts nor
encourage a return to wasteful and unsustainable fishing practices.
There are hard-line environment groups that are opposing this legislation purely
on ideological grounds and it will not be easy to gain passage with their well
financed opposition. It is important to keep in mind that this legislation has been
crafted with lots of input from both recreational and commercial fishermen who truly
understand the need for a sustainable future resource, and the rights of anglers
to have access to those resources. Our federal fisheries law needs to be fixed
now or more unnecessary closures and an economic collapse of our industry are imminent.
Unless we put tremendous pressure on our elected officials, nothing will change.
The bottom line is that the nation's primary fisheries law is broken and must be
amended immediately! If fishermen and industry stand together, Congress will make
the necessary changes. But without a united effort we are in big trouble. Recreational
fishermen were conservationists long before the environmental fringe got involved
with ocean issues pushing its "Sky is Falling" agenda. Anglers have proven to be
concerned and responsible stewards of our resources and have never been afraid
to do what's necessary to protect fisheries, the environment and the sport we love.
The Recreational Fishing Alliance (RFA) has filed suit in Federal Court to stop
the closures of both the black sea bass and the red snapper fisheries along the
East Coast and, along with several other organizations, are planning a massive rally
on the steps of the Capitol in Washington D.C. on February 24, 2010. It will be
an organized demonstration against the unintended negative impacts of the Magnuson
Stevens Conservation and Management Act as currently enacted. You or representatives
from your organization need to attend this rally. While your there, ask to be involved
in direct meetings with your state legislators on the Hill. With your help, we can
protect the rights of all fishermen. The RFA is organizing the lobbying effort and
much of the rally. They can be reached at 609-404-1060. Additional information is
available on their website at www.joinRFA.org
I strongly encourage you to get involved. The future of our sport and your business
depends on it!
Bob Flocken
Southern Kingfish Association

(The RFA thanks Bob Flocken and the Southern Kingfish Association for permission
to reprint the preceding letter, and for their continued support of our national
efforts to safeguard the rights of saltwater anglers, protect marine, boat and tackle
industry jobs, and ensure the long-term sustainability of our nation's saltwater

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Recreational Fishing Alliance | 176B South New York Rd | Galloway | NJ | 08205
RFA-NJ Member

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:55 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.