There are pros and cons for various boots and which bottom they have.
Felt has been known to transfer diseases included didymo (rock snot). But it sticks good on slippery stuff. With some boot manufacturers, you can add spikes to the felt. Spikes come in also different shapes and sizes (and prices). For me, any boots that I own, whether felt or rubber soled, have some form of spike in them.
Benefits of rubber soled boots are no disease transfer, and if you ever have to walk in the snow, you'll appreciate it (Felt is like a sponge on snow, and you'll have 5" of hard pack on your soles if they get wet and you walk through the snow). Rubber doesn't stick as good, but nothing a quality set of carbide spikes won't fix.
As for boots - Cabelas is always good for on the cheap (but they work). I prefer Chota boots - they are the widest boot I've ever owned, and I prefer that. They also have a "speed lace" system. Not the Velcro you were looking for, but not a bad option.
Simms - Love my Muckboot Waders (strictly for warmth)- but hate Simms boots (and waders). So no, not everyone thinks Simms is the greatest.
