[NJ Dave]

First off if this is a maiden voyage please wear a pfd. Also remember the water is still cold so if you tank without a dry suit be prepared for the worst.
Remember, you need to dress for the water temp,not the air temp.
With that said, local to Bergen co we don't have too much lake wise. Tilcon lake holding salmon or potash is lose to us. If I was to choose round Valley. Deep clear and has plenty to to catch. Watch the wind there tho. I always like the lakes up around west Milford off of skyline road.
Greenwood lake or Lake Hopatcong is another option.
Have fun, be safe.