If you're willing to take a longer drive, I've had a couple really nice trips to Black Lake, NY. Lots of pike and bass with opportunities for musky, walleye or even lake sturgeon. Panfishing is excellent as well. There are few lakeside cabin places that are inexpensive and you can rent boats and get food, bait and tackle. The lake is only about 20 minutes from the Canadien border and we fished one day on the St. Lawrence and I stuck, among other fish, a fatty northern off a weedline in 25-feet of water. The Larry is crystal clear b/c of the zebra mussels so the weedlines grow very deep. It's kind of a cool place if you've never been. I went up to Black Lake twice and caught plenty of fish both times. Totally worth it and I'd go back in heartbeat.
Here's a pic of the northern.
