Carnegie Lake
 

Hey guys Don't post that often but always check site out Would like a little input if anyone can help Thinking about trying out a new lake this year Have read Carnegie Lake has a public boat ramp and allows electric motors. Would like to know if its worth the trip out there for the day as I don't see much posted about it Know its decent size. I'm in Monmouth county and would hate to drive an hour or so and find out not worth the time. Thanks for any info anyone can provide

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

If you go @ prime time AND cover EVERY bit of shorline, you wont be disappointed......hope it helps:D

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

I've spent a good deal of time on this lake. There's plenty of good size LMBs in there. The boat ramp in of Route 27, almost at the end of the lake, on the Kingston end. There are fish up there and definitely along the shoreline. Do yourself a favor and check the PU Athletics schedule to make sure that you're not trying to go on a race day.

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Thanks appreciate the info and for the boat ramp location

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

I fish that lake from the Aqueduct a lot. If you work the shoreline in a boat in warm water you should catch a lot of bass to 5 lb and possibly a big muskie or pickerel. I caught 16.5" crappie, 10 lb channel catfish, 24 lb carp, 27 lb snapper, 17" rainbow trout, muskies and 5 species of catfish there. The lake is shallow with no cover.

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

I think the big fish kill-off last year has hurt the population of baitfish and possibly bass in Carnegie, along with the cormorants. I live 2 minutes away and fish it from my boat quite frequently. I'll start hitting it again regularly in the next couple of weeks and I'll post updates on what I see.

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Again thanks for the info about Carnegie Do have a jon boat so will definitely follow the shore line Looking forward to trying a new place Usually try to hit one new lake each year

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Can you use electric motors in there?

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Yes. Electric only. I use my kayak.

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Really? Must have come in from the Canal.

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

or Stony Brook

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Took a ride to Carnegie lake today to check lake and boat ramp Found it with no problem Looks like a nice place to try Better ramp than what im used to Place I usually go just a mud lauch area and shallow In a Monmouth county park So again thanks for the info guys

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

See ya out there one day!

Re: Carnegie Lake
 

Good point, but the lake is a pretty good distance from the local stocking points. Very possible though.