Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

Nah, definitely not a pickerel.

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

I would definetly say it is a Pike. I have attached a photo of a
small Tiger we caught this past weekend at Little Swartswood.

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

That thing is gorgeous! Nice first post!

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

Fella's its not a pike or a musky for sure..But its a hybrid pickerel & pike...Both live in many waters together...Kind of rare but there are a good number caught up state N.Y. Especially Lake Champlain..

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

You mean a liger pike?

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

No not a Tiger Pike..But a hybrid where a pickerel breeds with a Pike..Thats what that picture is...No Musky involved there...Its a Pike Pikerel sounds weird but thats what that is...

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

I understood what you are talking about, I call that a liger pike. Its a humorous reference to Napoleon Dynamite.

Liger = Lion + Tiger, if you haven't seen the movie.

Pike + Musky = Tiger Musky

Pike + Pickerel = Liger Pike

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

Interesting thought Fish n jeep...Guess since I didn't see that flick, had no clue where u where coming from....Anyway was an interesting thread, no one had a clue what type of fish it was...Figured I'd help everyone out...Don't see very many of them around..

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

LMAO well said.

Re: fish id: pike or tiger muskie
 

Not many do. :D