NJFishing.com Your Best Online Source for Fishing Information in New Jersey

- NJFishing.com Salt Water Fishing (https://www.njfishing.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=1)

- - To fluke in NY or NJ? (https://www.njfishing.com/forums/showthread.php?t=67539)

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

Mike,If I fished NY and Nj I still wouldn't be able to come up with 5 total.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

I am going to rape ny waters this year!

Also if ever stopped will make sur I tell co's all fish were caught in ny. Let it go towards their quota

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

What would be great is if all the Atlantic Highlands party boats went over to the NY side everyday. I think that would get some attention.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

I rarely saw N.Y. boats fishing in N.J. for fluke. Maybe an occasional PB but very few privates except in Ambrose. The size and bag limits on the N.Y. guys have been extremely severe. Imagine if it was us! The N.Y. guys were in the same mess as we were/are. The NMFS dictated their regulations with the same flawed data that they used to dictate ours. Don't take it out on the N.Y. guys. They went through a lot and still managed to keep their heads and catch keeper N.Y. fish during it all. It's an even playing field now. If they catch fish in N.J. waters it counts against their quotas. If we catch them in N.Y. waters, it counts against ours. this is not a contest between two states. It should be a bond between two neighbors who have a common interest for laws that are sound and sensible for everyone. One last thing.......the N.Y guys seem to have managed to keep the bunker boats out of their side of the Raritan which has helped us to a degree even though we don't have the same luxury.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by billfish715 (Post 348276)

i rarely saw n.y. Boats fishing in n.j. For fluke. Maybe an occasional pb but very few privates except in ambrose. The size and bag limits on the n.y. Guys have been extremely severe. Imagine if it was us! The n.y. Guys were in the same mess as we were/are. The nmfs dictated their regulations with the same flawed data that they used to dictate ours. Don't take it out on the n.y. Guys. They went through a lot and still managed to keep their heads and catch keeper n.y. Fish during it all. It's an even playing field now. If they catch fish in n.j. Waters it counts against their quotas. If we catch them in n.y. Waters, it counts against ours. This is not a contest between two states. It should be a bond between two neighbors who have a common interest for laws that are sound and sensible for everyone. One last thing.......the n.y guys seem to have managed to keep the bunker boats out of their side of the raritan which has helped us to a degree even though we don't have the same luxury.

amen.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

I don't believe much of this was directed to the NY anglers in general as much as it was one individual who chose to rub $h!t in our faces and constantly negative....my .02

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by shrimpman steve (Post 348174)

I am going to rape ny waters this year!

Also if ever stopped will make sur I tell co's all fish were caught in ny. Let it go towards their quota

it doesn't matter if you report/rape ny waters, the quota's are across the board from nj,ct,ny, it all counts as ONE..:)

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by italianfisherman (Post 348354)

it doesn't matter if you report/rape ny waters, the quota's are across the board from nj,ct,ny, it all counts as ONE..:)

Italian
Your right. Just a sensitive subject.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by italianfisherman (Post 348354)

it doesn't matter if you report/rape ny waters, the quota's are across the board from nj,ct,ny, it all counts as ONE..:)

If you looked at the reports we have to fill out every month to maintain our NY permit you would be amazed. If it helped I wouldn't care but it doesn't.

Re: To fluke in NY or NJ?

this whole thing is screw up..